A frantic 911 call from an Ohio father reporting that his four-month-old twin baby girl had stopped breathing has led to murder charges and a 𝓈𝒽𝓸𝒸𝓀𝒾𝓃𝑔 twist, with the child’s mother also now behind bars. Andrew Camerer, 30, told dispatchers on November 4, 2024, that his daughter Evelyn had fallen from a changing table while he was caring for her and her twin sister at their home in Green Township, a suburb of Cincinnati. The call, captured on police audio, reveals a man in distress, insisting he had not harmed his children. “I don’t want to hurt my babies. I love them so much,” Camerer is heard saying. But investigators quickly grew skeptical, as the injuries described by medical staff were far more severe than what a simple fall would typically cause.
Evelyn was rushed to Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, where doctors delivered devastating news. The infant had suffered catastrophic brain damage due to a lack of oxygen, and her condition was deemed irreversible. “She’s basically going to end up being brain dead,” Camerer told detectives after speaking with physicians. The baby girl died later that night. An autopsy later revealed a horrific pattern of trauma, including significant internal injuries to her brain, spinal column, and liver. Medical examiners concluded these injuries were not consistent with an accidental fall from a changing table, which typically measures only about three feet in height. The findings prompted a deeper investigation into what truly happened that morning while the twins’ mother, Danielle Rudy, was at work in Dayton.
During the initial 911 call, Camerer offered a detailed but confusing account of the incident. He claimed he was changing Evelyn’s diaper when she spit out her pacifier. As he turned to retrieve it, he said the baby pushed herself off the table using her legs, a motion he attributed to her acid reflux. “She pushed herself off and it was like too late before I could even do anything,” he told the dispatcher. He described trying to catch her but failing, and then watching her struggle to breathe. “She starts changing colors, right? She starts turning white. So now I’m like freaking the out like what is going on? What did I just do? Is it my fault?” Camerer said. He maintained this story when police arrived at his home, showing them the changing table and the spot where Evelyn allegedly landed on the carpeted floor.
Detectives, however, were unconvinced. Body camera footage from the scene shows officers pressing Camerer for more details, noting the changing table had a concave, rounded surface that made it unlikely for a baby to roll off. “It doesn’t look like it would even be possible to land in this little area, right?” one detective said. Camerer insisted his daughter was unusually mobile for a four-month-old, pushing with her feet and arching her back. But the medical evidence told a different story. Doctors informed investigators that Evelyn’s injuries, including bruising on her belly and a busted lip, pointed to something far more violent, such as shaking or blunt force trauma. “This is not consistent with just a baby falling,” a detective told Camerer during questioning at the hospital.
Camerer’s demeanor during the interrogation shifted between grief and self-preservation. He expressed fear of being sent to prison, telling detectives, “Danielle, they’re going to send me to jail, but you can sell the house, you make the money, pay off your things.” He also admitted to having a difficult year, citing financial stress and arguments with Rudy. When asked if he had ever shaken Evelyn, Camerer denied it, saying, “I don’t feel like I shook her. I really don’t.” Yet, he later seemed to acknowledge the possibility of a mistake, stating, “If I had not put her down on that table, if I had not walked away, my child will be alive.” The detectives noted a hole in the wall of the family’s home, which Camerer explained was from a night terror months earlier, but they saw it as a potential sign of volatility.
The case took a dramatic turn when investigators turned their attention to Rudy. Initially, she defended Camerer, telling detectives she believed he was a good father who knew when to walk away from stressful situations. “He would lay her down in her crib and walk away,” she said. But weeks after Camerer’s arrest, Rudy was brought back for questioning, and her story changed dramatically. She described their relationship as emotionally and mentally abusive, saying Camerer had her “under his thumb.” She revealed that he had made comments about not knowing his own strength and that their arguments often escalated over finances or perceived infidelity. “In hindsight, through the therapy I’ve been through now, it was emotionally and mentally abusive,” Rudy told detectives.
This new testimony led to a stunning development. In December 2024, a grand jury indicted Rudy on charges of complicity to murder in Evelyn’s death and child endangering for injuries to the surviving twin, who was found to have broken ribs. Prosecutors argued that Rudy failed to protect her children from Camerer’s 𝓪𝓫𝓾𝓼𝓮, despite knowing about his violent tendencies. The indictment sent shockwaves through the community, as many had initially viewed Rudy as a grieving mother rather than a suspect. Legal experts noted that complicity charges in such cases are rare but can be pursued when a parent is aware of a pattern of 𝓪𝓫𝓾𝓼𝓮 and does nothing to intervene.
Camerer eventually pleaded guilty to charges of involuntary manslaughter, felonious assault, and obstruction of justice. In a court hearing, he admitted to causing Evelyn’s death but stopped short of detailing the exact mechanism of injury. He was sentenced to 19 to 24 and a half years in prison, a term that will keep him behind bars well into his fifties. Rudy later pleaded guilty to two counts of child endangering, avoiding the more serious complicity charge. She received a five-year sentence, a punishment that some advocates say is too lenient given the severity of the case. Both parents are now serving their sentences in separate Ohio correctional facilities.
The case has sparked widespread debate about parental responsibility and the signs of 𝓪𝓫𝓾𝓼𝓮 that can go unnoticed. Child welfare experts emphasize that shaken baby syndrome, which often results in brain damage, blindness, or death, is entirely preventable. They urge parents to seek help if they feel overwhelmed, rather than resorting to violence. In this instance, the twins were just four months old, entirely dependent on their caregivers for survival. The surviving twin, now in the care of relatives, is expected to recover from her physical injuries but will carry the emotional scars of losing her sister and both parents to the justice system.
The 911 call, which lasted nearly 20 minutes, remains a haunting piece of evidence. In it, Camerer can be heard struggling to explain how a routine diaper change turned into a tragedy. “I’m just so scared,” he repeated, his voice cracking. The operator tried to keep him calm, instructing him on CPR as paramedics rushed to the scene. But for Evelyn, it was too late. The injuries she sustained were irreversible, and her death has left a void in the lives of those who knew her. Family members have described her as a happy baby who loved to stick out her tongue, a small gesture that Camerer mentioned during his interrogation, saying he teased her for it.
As the legal proceedings conclude, questions linger about what truly happened in that Green Township home. Camerer’s guilty plea provided some closure but left many details unanswered. The prosecution’s case relied heavily on medical evidence and Rudy’s later testimony, which painted a picture of a toxic relationship. Defense attorneys for both parents have declined to comment further, citing the ongoing appeals process. For now, the focus remains on the surviving twin, who is receiving care from extended family members. The community has rallied around her, setting up fundraisers and offering support as she grows up without her parents.
This case serves as a grim reminder of the fragility of life and the devastating consequences of unchecked anger. Andrew Camerer will spend nearly two decades in prison for his role in Evelyn’s death, while Danielle Rudy will serve five years for failing to stop it. The twin baby girl who survived will one day learn the truth about her sister and the parents who are now incarcerated. For now, she is safe, but the shadow of that November morning will linger forever.
https://www.youtube.com/embed/vqK7LL0LGwI
