Gal Gadot, the Israeli actress known for her role as Wonder Woman, is set to portray the iconic historical figure Cleopatra in an upcoming film. However, the casting decision has sparked significant controversy, reminiscent of the backlash that occurred when Elizabeth Taylor played the Egyptian queen in the 1960s.

Gadot, who has expressed a long-standing desire to tell Cleopatra’s story, faces criticism from various groups who argue that her portrayal is not historically accurate. The primary contention is centered around Cleopatra’s ethnicity. Many believe that Cleopatra, who ruled Egypt in the first century BC, was of African descent, while Gadot, who is of Israeli heritage, does not fit that description. Critics argue that casting a non-Black actress in this role perpetuates a tradition of misrepresentation in Hollywood, where stories and characters of color are often portrayed by white actors.

Additionally, there are historical complexities surrounding Cleopatra’s lineage. Born in Alexandria, Egypt, Cleopatra was of Macedonian Greek descent, belonging to the Ptolemaic dynasty that ruled Egypt after Alexander the Great’s conquest. While her Greek roots are undeniable, the cultural identity of Cleopatra has stirred debates, with some scholars and historians advocating for a more nuanced understanding of her heritage that acknowledges her connection to the Egyptian people.

Gadot has stated that her interpretation of Cleopatra will focus on the queen’s story from a woman’s perspective, highlighting her strength and political acumen in a male-dominated world. This approach aims to shed light on Cleopatra’s role as a powerful leader rather than merely a romantic figure in history.

Despite Gadot’s intentions, the backlash raises important questions about representation in film and the responsibilities of filmmakers when casting roles that have significant cultural and historical implications. The discussion surrounding this casting choice not only reflects ongoing conversations about race and representation in the entertainment industry, but also the complexities of historical narratives that often get simplified or overlooked.

As the film moves forward, it will undoubtedly continue to be a focal point for discussions about representation, identity, and the retelling of history through cinema. The challenge for filmmakers will be to balance artistic interpretation with the need for authenticity and respect for the diverse cultures and histories that shape our world.